User Unknown (WAS: really amazon?)

Wed Jul 31 20:55:39 UTC 2019

Scott, you might want to read "Policy Development Process (PDP)” https://www.arin.net/participate/policy/pdp/ in order to discover just exactly what John means by “If the community developed a policy”. 

You might also want to join the Public Policy Mailing List, arin-ppml at arin.net, to discuss.  Scintillating discourse, I assure you.

—Sandy

> On Jul 31, 2019, at 10:17 AM, Scott Christopher <sc at ottie.org> wrote:
> 
> John Curran wrote: 
> 
>> Scott - 
>> 
>> Alas, you have a fundamental misunderstanding about the nature of ARIN…  we don’t do anything other than implement policies that this community wants.  If the community developed a policy to require Abuse POC’s validation, and said policy made clear that failure to do so was to result in revocation, then ARIN would indeed implement the policy (and that includes revocation for those who ignored the policy.) 
> 
> Hello John - you are absolutely right. Since the community has shown overwhelming disapproval of Amazon's invalid abuse POC, please go ahead and revoke Amazon's resources.
> 
> Maybe do this late Friday afternoon for the courtesy toward Amazon's support staff ?
> 
> And since this will certainly be historic, please post an announcement to nanog-list ?
> 
> Thanks, and Good luck !
> 
> S.C.