Anyone using?

Fri Oct 29 12:20:52 UTC 1999

Simon,

You missed the question. Timothy is interested in finding companies who have
deployed the latest generation of edge devices. These devices specialize in
QoS, VPNs and more intelligent(CPU intensive) features. A GSR is not in the
same classification since this router is meant for the core. Vendors
competing in the edge space are Shasta, Ennovate, Cosine and Unisphere to
name a few. 

CF  

-----Original Message-----
From: Simon Lockhart [mailto:simonl at rd.bbc.co.uk]
Sent: Friday, October 29, 1999 5:19 AM
To: Alex P. Rudnev
Cc: Timothy Brown; nanog at merit.edu
Subject: Re: Anyone using? 

>Let me change your question a little...
>
>Most hw vendors announces now intergared router-switches (CISCO
>NORTEL, etc); usially it is very fast but limited-features devices.
>
>The question - is anyone using such devices in the production networ? In
>the ISP network?

We were close to getting some for our network, but were unable to get any 
hard facts about people who are using them as "backbone" or "border" 
routers. In the end, we've decided to go with Cisco GSR's.

The flaws we tended to find were with not enough enough memory to hold 
full routing tables, or a limit on the number of route entries. Another 
flaw was mentioned with regard to the route caching - something about 
needing to hold in table of which IP addresses were on which port (usual 
switch behaviour).

Simon

-- 
Simon Lockhart                      |   Tel: 01737 839676                
Senior R&D Engineer, Online         |   Fax: 01737 839665                
BBC Research & Development          | Email: Simon.Lockhart at rd.bbc.co.uk 
Kingswood Warren, Tadworth, Surrey. |   URL: http://www.bbc.co.uk/rd/