looking for hostname geographic hint validation

Ben ben+nanog at list-subs.com
Wed Aug 28 15:07:44 UTC 2013

Dear Bradley,

So basically you're asking others to do your homework for you ?

The only useful purpose your list serves is to demonstrate why people 
shouldn't try to build fancy algorithms that rely on an entirely 
unreliable datasource.

All you end up with are hacked together algorithms that contain a whole 
load of assumptions and will be obsolete by the time you release version 
1.0 because people will have changed their naming conventions a million 

For example, picking one example from your list ....


ic.ac.uk = Imperial College.  A well known and respected ivory towers 
institution in the UK.  The vast majority of their campus sites are 
located in London and only one or to outside London in South East England.

It is therefore very unlikely they'll be using IATA code, infact, last 
time I checked they were using conventions such as 
hostname.doc.ic.ac.uk, hostname.ch.ic.ac.uk.

Far from being IATA codes, the intermediate subdomains actually refer to 
departments (DepartmentOfComputing and CHemistry in the two I quoted).

Sorry to rain on your parade, but someone had to say it.

More information about the NANOG mailing list