Comcast Ethernet Feed

John Neiberger jneiberger at gmail.com
Fri Mar 30 02:16:53 UTC 2012


On Thu, Mar 29, 2012 at 8:02 PM, Brian R. Watters <brwatters at absfoc.com> wrote:
>
>
> A couple of questions -
>
> 1) What flavor of NPE are you using?
>
> NPE-G1
>
> 2) Is the GigE interface on the NPE-G1/G2  OR is this a PA?
> 3) Is the FaE ethernet interface that you appear to be connecting your laptop to, on a separate PA in chassis?
>
> Laptop connected directly to router via slot 4  PA-FE-TX
>
> 4) Have you verified you that "bandwidth-points" have not been exceeded for bus-1 and/or 2: slots 1,3,5 for bus1 and 2,4,6; also 0(if I/O controller is present. It is 600 points for bus1 and 600 for bus2.
>
> PCI bus mb1 has 390 bandwidth points
> PCI bus mb2 has 500 bandwidth points
>
>
> Have you *hard-coded* speed and duplex on any of you eth ints? Please don't!
>
> GIGE has been both hard and auto .. same results .. Fast Ether has always been set @ auto
>
> Let both ints auto-negotiate speed&duplex.
>
> Comcast states that we are required to have a hard code FULL DUPLEX and SPEED 100 as well as flow control OFF however I can not appear to be able to disable it :(

If the Comcast side is hard-coded to 100/Full then you really only
have one choice, set your side to 100/Full, as well. For the past
decade, Cisco gear completely disables autonegotiation if you hard set
the speed and duplex settings. Some equipment still participates in
auto even when you hard set it. That's why you occasionally get duplex
mismatches even when both sides are hard set. The side that
participates in auto will expect to see an autonegotiating link
partner. When it doesn't see one, it drops back to half duplex because
it assumes it is connected to a hub (This is for Fast Ethernet.)

So, if you connect a piece of Cisco gear and it is hard set to
100/full, you'll be fine. If you connect a laptop or some other device
with a NIC that still participates in auto even when you hard set the
settings, you won't get that to work well.




More information about the NANOG mailing list