Rich_Andreas at Cable.Comcast.com
Wed Mar 11 20:20:49 UTC 2009
I have found that Cisco IPSLA is heavily used in the MSO/Service
Provider Space. Juniper has equivalent functionality via RPM.
From: Saqib Ilyas [mailto:msaqib at gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, March 07, 2009 6:12 AM
To: nanog at nanog.org
Subject: Re: Network SLA
I must thank everyone who has answered my queries. Just a couple more
For instance, if one is using MRTG, and wants to check if we can meet
a 1 Mbps end-to-end throughput between a couple of customer sites, I
believe you would need to use some traffic generator tools, because
MRTG merely imports counters from routers and plots them. Is that
We've heard of the BRIX active measurement tool in replies to my
earlier email. Also, I've found Cisco IP SLA that also sends traffic
into the service provider network and measures performance. How many
people really use IP SLA feature?
Thanks and best regards
On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 1:19 PM, Zartash Uzmi <zartash at gmail.com> wrote:
> As I gather, there is a mix of answers, ranging from "building the
> according to requirements and HOPE for the best" to "use of arguably
> sophisticated tools and perhaps sharing the results with the legal
> I would be particularly interested in hearing the service providers'
> viewpoint on the following situation.
> Consider a service provider with MPLS deployed within its own network.
> (A) When the SP enters into a relation with the customer, does the SP
> establish new MPLS paths based on customer demands (this is perhaps
> to "building" based on requirements as pointed out by David)? If yes,
> between what sites/POPs? I assume the answer may be different
> a single-site customer or a customer with multiple sites.
> (B) For entering into the relationship for providing X units of
> (to another site of same customer or to the Tier-1 backbone), does the
> use any wisdom (in addition to MRTG and the likes)? If so, what
> parameters are kept in mind?
> (C) How does the customer figure out that a promise for X units of
> is maintained by the SP? I believe customers may install some
> tools but is that really the case in practice?
> On Fri, Feb 20, 2009 at 1:16 AM, Stefan <netfortius at gmail.com> wrote:
>> Saqib Ilyas wrote:
>>> I am curious to know about any tools/techniques that a service
>>> to assess an SLA before signing it. That is to say, how does an
>>> administrator know if he/she can meet what he is promising. Is it
>>> experience? Are there commonly used tools for this?
>>> Thanks and best regards
>> Not necessarily as a direct answer (I am pretty sure there'll be
>> this list giving details in the area of specific tools and
standards), but I
>> think this may be a question (especially considering your end result
>> concern: *signing the SLA!) equally applicable to your legal
>> the environment we live, nowadays, the SLA could (should?!? ...
>> unfortunately) be "refined" and (at the other end - i.e. receiving)
>> "interpreted" by the lawyers, with possibly equal effects (mostly
>> and as overall impact on the business) as the tools we (the technical
>> people) would be using to measure latency, uptime, bandwidth, jitter,
Muhammad Saqib Ilyas
PhD Student, Computer Science and Engineering
Lahore University of Management Sciences
More information about the NANOG