dns - golog

Martin Hannigan hannigan at renesys.com
Sun Oct 22 06:25:26 UTC 2006

Simon Waters wrote:

>On Friday 20 Oct 2006 00:35, you wrote:

[ SNIP ]

>I think one problem is that IANA doesn't have a "brand name", so when you buy

IANA has nothing to do with routing policy and neither does ICANN. ICANN
has no authority through any contract vehicle inside any network. Do you
have some information contrary to that?

>an Internet connection you aren't told you are getting an IANA DNS,

There's no such a thing as IANA DNS. The DoC controls the root DNS
zone file. IANA distributes and does change management.

>  that is
>assumed. The interesting question is whether that is sustainable if a lot of
>ISPs provide a non-IANA DNS service. There may be an argument for saying that
>"non IANA DNS" services can't be described as "Internet services", but that
>is an issue for ICANNs lawyers.

No, actually, it's not.

> > 
> <http://www.circleid.com/posts/techies_wanna_do_policy/>http://www.circleid.com/posts/techies_wanna_do_policy/
>Karl was so wrong on the F root-server issue. Paul asserted no new 
>right, most

ISC asserted that they own IP address space and can control the
routability, contrary to standard Internet and operator policy.
They can't, and I doubt anyone is very worried about a lawsuit
from ISC. Legal geniuses they are not.


Martin Hannigan                                (c) 617-388-2663
Renesys Corporation                            (w) 617-395-8574
Member of Technical Staff                      Network Operations
                                                hannigan at renesys.com  

More information about the NANOG mailing list