209.68.1.140 (209.68.1.0 /24) blocked by bellsouth.net for SMTP

Suresh Ramasubramanian ops.lists at gmail.com
Mon Sep 26 04:06:57 UTC 2005


On 26/09/05, Sean Figgins <sean at labrats.us> wrote:
> And if the customer specifically requests that YOU do not filter his
> email, or set up a system that allows him to see ALL email, even if ti is
> tagged as spam?

sell the customer a colo box or a virtual private server and have him
do whatever he wants with it

commodity / customer mailserver operations do involve filtering

> provider, and they may all be very true, but it does not change the truth
> that a single false positive can ruin a business.

If you filter spam, return clear bounce messages that show why the
filtering was done. Ideally return a url in the bounce message that
links to a clear explanation + tells you what to do about it.   And a
response mechanism to handle false positive reports, that addresses
these ASAP.

Just for example (and never mind the content .. 127.0.0.2 is a generic
address thats inserted in most blocklists) - 
http://spamblock.outblaze.com/127.0.0.2

Bad spam filtering is what gives all filtering a bad name ... what I
would call the Wile E Coyote school of spam filtering.  Like a trained
mining engineer can use a fused bundle of dynamite to blow a hole in a
rock - he'll blow up just what he wants to blow up, nothing else. 
Give Wile E Coyote that dynamite and ask him to blow up the roadrunner
.. you know what happens next.

-srs



More information about the NANOG mailing list