How do you stop outgoing spam?
Rafi Sadowsky
rafi-nanog at meron.openu.ac.il
Tue Sep 10 20:55:16 UTC 2002
## On 2002-09-10 13:41 -0700 Tony Hain typed:
TH>
TH> Rafi Sadowsky wrote:
TH> > How about using a combination of technical and "social"
TH> > measures For example in a Cyber Cafe use passive technical
TH> > measures to count the total number of outbound SMTP sessions
TH> > and charge 1$ per Email over an average rate of 2
TH> > Emails/minute and 10$ per Email exceeding a rate of 10 per minute
TH>
TH> So the person who connects after sitting on a plane for 5 hours gets
TH> charged extra because the laptop bursts 50 messages ...
Well the numbers may need adjusting but please note that I
suggested measuring the average not burst - so if said person buys 30
minutes online his *average* rate would be (just) under the
2 Emails/minute threshold
If needed change the first threshold to 4/5 per minute and the second
threshold to 20 per minutes
TH> There is no
TH> automated technical approach to a social problem. Public executions
TH> would be much more effective than preventing legitimate customers from
TH> getting their job done.
True in many cases but the punishment should be reasonable
You could define SPAM as theft in Saudi-Arabia & then a a spammer would
probably have his right hand chopped off ...
A little common sense would probably be useful in matching the punishment
to the "crime"
TH>
TH> Tony
TH>
--
Rafi
More information about the NANOG
mailing list