Spam. Again.. -- and blocking net blocks?

Stephen Sprunk ssprunk at
Tue Dec 10 22:30:15 UTC 2002

Barry Shein wrote:
> The only solution to spam is to start charging for email (perhaps with
> reasonable included minimums if that calms you down for some large set
> of "you") and thus create an economic incentive for all parties
> involved.
> Face it folks, the party is over, the free-for-all was a nice idea but
> it simply did not work. See "The Tragedy of the Commons".

Sure, because charging for postal mail has certainly stopped the deplorable
practice of junk mailing.</sarcasm>

As long as spamming is legal, people will do it, period.  You cannot solve
administrative problems with technical solutions.  The key is for ISPs to
form a political lobby (with the same power as the DMA) and push for
reasonable laws to protect consumers.  Until then, we're all pissing in the


More information about the NANOG mailing list