Zone file access
jamie at dilbert.ais.net
Fri May 15 15:19:43 UTC 1998
Paul Vixie wrote:
> If NSI should ask me to restrict outbound zone transfers, then I would of
> course immediately ask the IANA whether to comply with that request.
There are issues that come up outside of just "I want the COM tld", which
I haven't seen anyone address yet:
- Registration of domain names under NDA;
- Registration/Allocation of IP addresses under NDA.
By "under NDA," I mean, for example, this: Company X wants to get a /19
for its Internet gatewaying to the Internet. They will give information
to ARIN to justify the IP addresses (which there /is/ an NDA agreement for);
however, they do not want contact information available on the Internet.
Say they want the same for their domain name - Something that doesn't really
make sense, like XYTSDGC.COM, a "secret" domain name for their outside
sales force, extranet/customer information, etc. -- Yes, it's not really
a "right" thing, because if abuse comes from that IP range or gatewayed via
a mail relay from xytsdgc.com (or some other abuse) it becomes difficult to
track -- But the issue still exists.
I wonder if this has been brought up before, and what the results of this
have been (and if NSI or ARIN have replied publicly).
Back on topic--
As far as the root zones go, those userid/password combos were only supposed
to be given out to iTLD and root server operators. It didn't exactly go
that way.. I have one myself.. but I think NSI really is doing the "right
thing" by not giving out zones. The only reason I can think of, that one
would need an entire zone, would be for mailspamming. Other "useful"
things would be webcrawlers getting new zones (altho I dont think it's a good
idea to webcrawl without someone submitting), and to have statistics data.
None of which, just like this post, is critical or important to the operation
of the Internet. :-)
jamie rishaw (dal/efnet:gavroche) American Information Systems, Inc.
rdm: "Religion is obsolete." gsr: "By what?" jgr: "Solaris." (1996)
More information about the NANOG