Exchanges that matter...
amb at xara.net
Sat Dec 7 16:08:02 UTC 1996
> "Alex.Bligh" <amb at xara.net> wrote
> > > I think that what Alex really should say 'No'. What he saying is
> > > that for Xara UK-sourced traffic is split like this:
> > > 50% is sent to UK peers at the LINX in London
> > > 40% goes to the USA
> > > 10% goes to dGIX in Stockholm
> > >
> > Doh! Yes. Must get reading lessons. Missed the word "remaining".
> So none of the traffic from Xara goes back out to Xara customers?!
Yes of course, esp news. between our news machines and customers.
However I've discounted all (OK well most) inter-UK-customer traffic
before doing the calculation. The figures were measured through the
first UK router in our transit AS which peered at the time of measurement
with everyone in the UK and still peers with everyone significant
traffic wise within the UK. Traffic between UK customers doesn't
touch this router. As we are relatively small market share wise in
the UK cf market share of (say) MCI in the US, and as the UK is a small
% of the internet as a whole most "inter-customer" most traffic is
actually between customers and (say) our news machines, nameservers etc.
IE if our UK customer base was 1% of the Internet the most difference this
would make is 1%.
> > Currently I have no foolproof way to differentiate traffic that
> > goes over the LINX destined for in UK and outside UK. There's
> > some work going on to build a list of UK ASes to this end (amongst
> > others) but it hasn't been done yet.
> Quite agreed this is hard stuff, thus my interest :)
We're getting there. We are developing tools that break down traffic
flow stats into inter-AS flow stats, then in turn break these down
into the (commercial) sources of such flows. I'd like if possible
to consider "what if" scenarios. We already have some tools in perl
that "understand" BGP tables and AS paths - currently the main challenge
is grabbing the accounting data as we don't have NetFlow :-(
> > Jim is quite right (except it works bidirectionally).
> Do you see symmetrical flows in and out of the country or do you
> see more inbound that outbound?
That's currently a hard question as we're in the middle of mucking
the backbone about but last time I looked when it was set up in
a symmetrical way, the traffic was almost symmetric (volume wise).
I'm going to see Jag at bt.net next week for a chat about this BTW - I
understand you have both been talking about similar stuff before.
More information about the NANOG