Verizon no BGP route to some of AS38365 (182.61.200.0/24)

Wed Jul 20 19:18:36 UTC 2022

To follow up on this:
I've engaged Verizon's executive office to finally try to get to a network
engineer (because I don't have a contact myself). The (proxied) response
from the engineer was that they aren't receiving any announcements for
these routes to AS701, and I would need to take it up with Baidu. I guess I
would like to understand if that seems reasonable to people since it is my
presumption that Baidu would return and say something similar (that they
advertise their routes to their peers correctly and to take it up with
Verizon). To me, it seems like there is clearly a failing in one of
Verizon's peers where they are not advertising or accepting this route
correctly, but that it would be incumbent on Verizon to do the legwork to
fix it since they are the ones who know their peering agreements and have
these contacts. Unfortunately it seems like policy that Verizon pushes any
issues that aren't internal routing issues to an external party, but surely
they have a responsibility to maintain their peering and routes to external
services as well. In other words, this type of buckpassing does not seem
right to me (and I've heard it from them on other routing issues before),
especially given that they are the ones empowered to fix it. Any thoughts?

(As it happens, pan.baidu.com now resolves to an IP range that is routable
by Verizon, but it could always revert, and it seems like Verizon should
have these routes regardless.)

Thanks.

On Fri, Jun 24, 2022 at 7:41 AM Matthew Huff <mhuff at ox.com> wrote:

> From my limited vantage point it appears that there is some issue between
> Verizon & Baidu. Baidu has 182.61.0.0/16 registered, but is only
> advertising pieces of it globally (or at least from what I can see). In our
> tables,we are receiving none from Verizon of  the subnets that are
> advertised directly from Baidu (origin AS of 38365). The few within that
> registered range that have a different origin AS are coming to us from
> Verizon. For example:
>
>
>
> *>   182.61.0.0/19    144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.0.0/18    144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.32.0/19   144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.64.0/18   204.148.121.221                        0 701 6453
> 55967 i
>
> *    182.61.128.0/23  204.148.121.221                        0 701 4134
> 4134 4134 4134 4134 58540 ?
>
> *>   182.61.130.0/24  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 23724 38365 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.130.0/23  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.131.0/24  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 23724 38365 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.132.0/23  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.132.0/22  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.134.0/23  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.136.0/22  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.136.0/21  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.140.0/22  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.144.0/21  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58466 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.144.0/20  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.160.0/19  204.148.121.221                        0 701 6453
> 55967 i
>
> *>   182.61.192.0/23  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58540 i
>
> *>   182.61.194.0/23  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 3356
> 4134 58540 i
>
> *>   182.61.200.0/22  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 23724 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.200.0/21  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.216.0/21  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.223.0/24  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
> *>   182.61.224.0/19  144.121.203.141                        0 46887 6461
> 4134 58466 38365 38365 i
>
>
>
> We are getting the 182.61.200.0/21 and 182.61.200.0/22 from all of our
> other peers:
>
>
>
> asr-inet2#sh ip bgp 182.61.200.0/21
>
> BGP routing table entry for 182.61.200.0/21, version 15779018
>
> Paths: (2 available, best #2, table default)
>
>   Advertised to update-groups:
>
>      3
>
>   Refresh Epoch 1
>
>   54004 6128 1299 4134 58466 38365 38365, (aggregated by 38365
> 119.75.208.225)
>
>     148.77.99.201 from 148.77.99.201 (24.157.4.25)
>
>       Origin IGP, localpref 100, valid, external, atomic-aggregate
>
>       rx pathid: 0, tx pathid: 0
>
>       Updated on Apr 29 2022 21:02:05 EDT
>
>   Refresh Epoch 1
>
>   46887 6461 4134 58466 38365 38365, (aggregated by 38365 119.75.208.225)
>
>     129.77.17.254 from 129.77.17.254 (129.77.40.7)
>
>       Origin IGP, metric 0, localpref 100, valid, internal,
> atomic-aggregate, best
>
>       rx pathid: 0, tx pathid: 0x0
>
>       Updated on May 3 2022 04:02:50 EDT
>
>
>
>
>
> *From:* NANOG <nanog-bounces+mhuff=ox.com at nanog.org> *On Behalf Of *
> holow29
> *Sent:* Thursday, June 23, 2022 5:49 PM
> *To:* nanog at nanog.org
> *Subject:* Verizon no BGP route to some of AS38365 (182.61.200.0/24)
>
>
>
> I've been trying (to no avail) for over a month now to get Verizon to
> investigate their lack of BGP routing to 182.61.200.0/24, which hosts
> Baidu Wangpan at  pan.baidu.com (Baidu's cloud services/equivalent of
> Google Drive).
>
>
>
> Easily verified through Verizon's Looking Glass.
>
>
>
> We all know Verizon's BGP routing is a disaster, but does anyone have any
> ideas?
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.nanog.org/pipermail/nanog/attachments/20220720/025a7b09/attachment.html>