[Nanog-futures] Fascist police force or team of gardeners?

[Robert E. Seastrom]

Stephen Wilcox <steve.wilcox at packetrade.com> writes:

> On 27 Nov 2007, at 14:34, <michael.dillon at bt.com> wrote:
>
>> Will NANOG become a better list with a team of fascist police officers
>> scrutinizing every posting?
>> http://www.infiltrated.net/nanogpolice.jpg
>
> clearly not but lets begin with the evidence :)

100% agreement with Steve here.  I've seen no indication that Marty's
sending out more email than I did when I was on the MLC; he's just
happened to send mail out to the list when he's had trouble contacting
people from his personal account.  That makes it a lot more visible.

I'm very interested in hearing about concrete criticism, constructive
or otherwise.  Blue sky "gee, it seems this way, I have a gut feeling"
stuff, not so much.

So Michael, let's hear what you've got...  other than a drop in list
traffic, which *just might* be attributable to a holiday week in the
USA where the majority of NANOG's constituents live.  Have you been
the recipient of a "sternly worded warning letter"?  Do you believe it
was warranted based on what you posted to the list and other
circumstances?  Have any other information to share that might be
interesting to the folks here on -futures, or is it just all blind
speculation?

Thanks!

                                        ---Rob